Home  |  Contact Us  |  Site Map Français  |  Español

Chart of substitutes

Substitutes not without risks


Download this chart (.pdf 36kb)

Substance Health effects Conclusions
Fibreglass

increased incidence of lung cancers in glass wool production workers (3)

listed by the U.S. as "a substance which may reasonably be anticipated to be a carcinogen" (4)

listed by German MAK Commission as "a substance to be treated as if a probable cause of cancer"

"Our review then examines the carcinogenic potency of glass fibers to humans in comparison with asbestos fibers and concludes that on a fiber-per-fiber basis, glass fibers may be as potent or even more potent than asbestos." (Infante et al., Am. J. Ind. Med., 1994)
Silicon carbide whiskers "Silicon carbide whiskers have the potential, at least, to cause significant immediate and long-term pulmonary damage. It appears to be more toxic than crocidolite." (Vaughan et al., Env. Res., 1993)
Glass and rock wool

IARC Class 3 “not classifiable as to carcinogenicity from humans”

Aramid fibre

has caused fibrosis and lung tumours in inhalation exposure studies on rats (1)

"exposures to these fibres should be controlled to the same degree as that required for asbestos until data supporting a lesser degree of control become available." (2)

"Results of cytotoxicity tests indicated that Aramid was as toxic to hamster trachael epithelial cells and rat lung fibroblast cells as were crocidolite and chrysotile asbestos when expressed on both an equal mass and equal fiber number basis." (Marsh et al., Drug and Chem. Toxic., 1994)
All respirable and durable fibres "Exposures to these fibres should be controlled to the same degree as that required for asbestos until data supporting a lesser degree of control become available." (IPCS, 1993)
Refractory ceramic fibre (RCF)

evidence of fibrogenicity and carcinogenicity in animal implantation and inhalation studies (5)

IARC Class 2B "possibly carcinogenic to man"

listed by German MAK Commission as "a substance with known carcinogenic potential in humans"

listed by the U.S. as a "probable human carcinogen"

"Both rats and hamsters exhibited dose-dependent increases in proliferation of pleural mesothelial cells following exposure to both fibre types (MMVF et RCF-1)." (Rutten et al., Fund Appl. Tox., 1994)
Magnesium sulfate fibre, calcium sulfate fibre and fibreglass "it is suggested that some of man-made fibers have a greater ability than asbestos to induce tumor." (Adachi et al., Environ. Research, 1991)
Carbon / graphite fibre

evidence of lung function deterioration in workers (1)

Phosphate fibre

intrapleural implantation in rats can induce fibrosarcomas (4)

Attapulgite

causes mesothelioma in experimental animals (7)

Wollastonite

evidence of lung fibrosis, pleural thickening and chronic bronchitis in humans (6)

(1) ILO Safety in the use of mineral and sythetic fibres, 1989, p. 40 
(2) IPCS Environmental Health Criteria 151, Selected Synthetic Organic Fibres, WHO, l993 
(3) Saracci, R. et al.(1984) Brit J Ind Med. 41:425-436 
(4) U.S. EPA, Status Report FTI-OTS-0386-0486, (1986) 
(5) Davis, JMG et al.(1983), Biological effects of man-made mineral fibres, Euro Reports and Studies: 81:p. 124 
(6) Huuskonen, M.S. et al.(1983) Environ. Res. 30:291-304 
(7) Pott, F. et al.(1976) Ann. Anat. Pathol. 21:237-246


 


SEE ALSO...
Alarm Rising in Denmark



International Chrysotile Association © All rights reserved | Contact us | Sitemap